10 Questions to Ask Your Criminal Defense Attorney if DNA Evidence Is Being Used in Your Case

DNA evidence is one of the most powerful tools used in modern criminal investigations. It is often portrayed as infallible — a silver bullet that can conclusively tie someone to a crime scene or prove their innocence. But the truth is more complicated. DNA evidence can be mishandled, misunderstood, overinterpreted, or even misrepresented. And jurors often place enormous weight on DNA, even when the underlying science is uncertain.

If you are facing criminal charges and DNA evidence is part of the case against you, it is essential to ask your criminal defense attorney the right questions. Doing so helps you understand the strengths and weaknesses of the prosecution’s evidence, identify opportunities to challenge the results, and play an active role in your defense.

This comprehensive guide covers 10 crucial questions to ask your criminal defense lawyer when DNA evidence is involved.

________________________________________

1. What type of DNA evidence is being used in my case, and how strong is it?

Not all DNA evidence is created equal. The type of DNA collected can dramatically impact how reliable it is, how it should be interpreted, and whether it can be successfully challenged. When discussing your case with your attorney, start with the foundational question: what kind of DNA evidence is the prosecution relying on?

Common Types of DNA Evidence

• Direct/Primary DNA Transfer – Occurs when bodily fluids like blood, semen, saliva, or skin cells are directly deposited. This is generally the strongest and most straightforward form.
• Touch DNA – Generated from only a few dozen skin cells. This form of DNA is very prone to transfer, contamination, and misinterpretation.
• Secondary or Tertiary Transfer DNA – Involves DNA being passed from person to object (or object to person) indirectly. A person may leave DNA on an item they never touched.
• Mixed DNA Samples – Samples containing DNA from multiple individuals. These are far more complex to analyze.
• Low‑copy or Low‑template DNA – Extremely small amounts of DNA that must be amplified to be tested, increasing the risk of unreliable results.

Why This Matters

Different types of DNA have different levels of legal impact.

•             Blood or semen at a crime scene might strongly indicate direct contact.

•             Touch DNA on a gun, however, could have arrived through completely innocent means.

Your attorney should explain:

•             What type of DNA was collected.

•             Whether the quantity was large or small.

•             Whether the collection method affects reliability.

•             Whether the evidence proves contact, presence, or nothing meaningful at all.

Understanding the type of DNA evidence is the first step in evaluating how strong the case truly is.

________________________________________

2. How was the DNA collected, preserved, and stored — and were the proper procedures followed?

DNA evidence can easily be contaminated, degraded, or compromised if law enforcement fails to follow established protocols. Even minor procedural errors can cast doubt on the reliability of test results.

Chain of Custody

Ask your attorney:

•             Who collected the DNA sample?

•             Where was it collected from?

•             How was it packaged?

•             Who handled it after collection?

•             Were there any gaps in the chain of custody records?

Any break in documentation can give weight to a challenge in court.

Collection and Preservation Issues

DNA samples should be:

•             Collected with sterile gloves and tools.

•             Packaged in paper, not plastic, to prevent moisture buildup.

•             Stored in temperature controlled environments.

•             Labeled correctly with time, date, and location.

If officers packaged DNA improperly or stored it under poor conditions, contamination or degradation becomes a real possibility.

Scene Contamination Risks

Crime scenes can be chaotic. DNA can be compromised by:

•             First responders.

•             Weather conditions.

•             Shared surfaces.

•             Poorly trained officers.

Your attorney can investigate whether there is any evidence to support that contamination occurred and whether that contamination could undermine the prosecution’s claims.

________________________________________

3. What lab performed the DNA testing, and what is its reputation, accreditation, and error history?

Not all labs operate at the same standards. Some are highly reputable, accredited, and known for meticulous work. Others have been shut down for misconduct, sloppy procedures, or falsifying results. And yet other labs who may be accredited can still have a reputation for less than stellar scientific work.

Why Lab Reputation Matters

Because DNA is so persuasive to juries, sloppy labs create a massive risk of wrongful convictions. Asking your attorney about the lab’s background can reveal:

•             Whether the lab is properly accredited.

•             Whether it has failed audits.

•             Whether its technicians have been disciplined.

•             Whether the lab or specific technician has made mistakes in previous cases.

•         Whether the lab has had results suppressed by Judges due to scientifically

        questionable practices.

Common Lab Problems

Some issues that arise in crime labs include:

•             Cross contamination of samples.

•             Data manipulation.

•             Inconsistent interpretation of mixed samples.

•             Technicians skipping quality control steps.

•             Mislabeling or swapping samples.

•        Labs not following their own standard operating procedures.
•        Standard operating procedures that are not supported by validation information.

Example: Lab Scandals/Closures

Major scandals have occurred in multiple states, including Massachusetts, Texas, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, California, and New York. These scandals involved:

•             Dry labbing (reporting results without actually running the tests).

•        Drug Testing procedural and training errors.

•             Mishandling thousands of samples.

•             Systemic quality failures.

Your attorney should independently evaluate the lab records and, if necessary, hire an expert to critique the lab’s methodology.

________________________________________

4. What testing method did the lab use, and is it reliable for this type of sample?

DNA evidence can be tested using various methods — some are robust and well validated, while others are newer, more subjective, or more prone to error.

Common Testing Methods

•             STR Analysis (Short Tandem Repeat) – The current gold standard for DNA profiling and typically the most reliable.

•             Y STR Testing – Tests only the Y chromosome and is used for male specific DNA, but cannot distinguish between male relatives.

•             mtDNA (Mitochondrial DNA) – Useful for degraded samples but not unique to individuals (shared maternally).

•             Rapid DNA Systems – Produce quick results but are less reliable and more prone to misuse.

•             Probabilistic Genotyping (e.g., STRmix, TrueAllele) – Software that interprets complex or low level mixtures and assigns a likelihood ratio to two competing hypothesis.

Key Questions for Your Lawyer

•             Is the testing method appropriate for the sample type and size?

•             Does this method have known accuracy limits?

•             Has the method been challenged in courts before?

•             Are the software programs used transparent or “black boxes” that hide how decisions are made?

Probabilistic genotyping software, in particular, has faced criticism for:

•             Producing inconsistent results between different software programs.

•             Being unreviewable due to proprietary algorithms.

•             Producing overstated statistical matches.

Your attorney should ensure the testing method is scientifically valid and legally reliable.

________________________________________

5. Did the DNA results involve a mixture, low copy DNA, or partial profiles — and how does that impact reliability?

DNA mixtures and low copy samples are among the most complicated and error prone types of evidence used in court.

Mixture DNA Profiles

These occur when the sample contains genetic material from multiple individuals. They are notoriously hard to interpret because:

•             Analysts must determine the number of contributors.

•             Minor contributors can be easily misinterpreted.

•             Software assisted interpretation can vary drastically.

Low Copy or Low Template DNA

This type of DNA involves:

•             Extremely small amounts of genetic material.

•             High risk of contamination.

•             The need for significant amplification (which can distort the profile).

Partial or Degraded Profiles

A profile may be incomplete due to age, environmental exposure, or improper storage. Partial profiles often:

•             Produce ambiguous results.

•             Increase the risk of false inclusions.

•             Rely heavily on interpretation rather than objective data.

These types of samples can be successfully challenged if your attorney understands the underlying weaknesses.

________________________________________

6. What are the statistical findings, and what do the numbers actually mean?

DNA results come with statistical interpretations.  These statistics are frequently misunderstood by juries and even attorneys.

Common DNA Statistics

•             Random Match Probability (RMP) – The chance that a random person would have the same DNA profile.

•             Likelihood Ratios – Compare two hypotheses, such as “the defendant contributed DNA” vs. “an unknown, unrelated person contributed DNA.”

•             CPI – Combined Probability of Inclusion: CPI estimates the probability that a random, unrelated person could be included as a contributor to the DNA mixture. Put another way, CPI tells you how likely it is that someone other than the defendant could also fit the DNA profile.

•             Inclusion/Exclusion Statements – Whether the person can be included or excluded as a contributor.

Why Statistics Can Be Misleading

A statistic such as “1 in a trillion” does not always mean the DNA definitely came from the defendant. Instead, it often means:

•             If the DNA came from a single source, and

•             If the sample is complete and uncontaminated,

•             Then the odds of another person matching are extremely low.

But if the sample is mixed, degraded, or amplified, those statistics become far less meaningful.

Ask Your Attorney

•             What statistical method did the lab use?

•             Were the numbers calculated correctly?

•             Do the statistics reflect strong, weak, or inconclusive results?

A good defense attorney may hire an independent DNA expert to re evaluate the stats and identify errors.

________________________________________

7. Was an independent DNA expert consulted, and should one be hired?

Most criminal defense attorneys are not scientists, and DNA is extremely complex. Hiring an independent expert can be essential to:

•             Analyze the raw data.

•             Identify errors made by the state’s lab.

•             Challenge improper statistical interpretations.

•             Testify persuasively to a jury.

Why an Independent Expert Matters

An outside expert can uncover issues such as:

•             Contamination.

•             Mixed sample misinterpretation.

•             Incorrect assumptions made by lab analysts.

•             Failure to follow proper protocols.

•        Standard Operating Procedures that are not supported by the validation data.

In many cases, independent experts have successfully demonstrated and testified to flaws that resulted in reduced charges, outright dismissals, or acquittals.

If your attorney has not yet consulted an expert, ask whether doing so is appropriate in your case.

________________________________________

8. Could the DNA have been transferred indirectly — even if I never touched the object or was never at the scene?

DNA transfer is one of the most misunderstood aspects of forensic science.

Types of DNA Transfer

•             Primary Transfer – Direct contact.

•             Secondary Transfer – DNA is transferred through a third party or object.

•             Tertiary Transfer – DNA is transferred through multiple intermediaries.

In real world settings, DNA moves easily. The more research that has been done on transfer the more we are coming to learn just how easily DNA can transfer and how unpredictable it can be to say anything about how DNA arrived on an item of evidence.

Examples:

•             A person’s DNA can end up on a gun they never touched if someone else handled both the person and the gun.

•             DNA can transfer to clothing during everyday contact.

•             DNA can land on objects simply by being near them.

•         DNA can be found all over the areas where a person lives or spends frequent time at

When Transfer Matters

If the prosecution claims your DNA was found on:

•             A weapon

•             Clothing

•             A doorknob

•             A vehicle interior

•             A piece of evidence you never handled

… then transfer is a major issue.

Ask your attorney whether transfer may be an appropriate challenge in your case.

________________________________________

9. How will the prosecution present the DNA evidence in court, and how can it be challenged effectively?

Juries often give DNA evidence tremendous weight. That means your attorney must be prepared not only to challenge the science but also to counter the psychological impact of the prosecution’s presentation. Ask your attorney what their defense strategy is and how they intend to litigate issues in your case?

Prosecution Tactics

Prosecutors may:

•             Present DNA as infallible.

•             Use complex statistics to overwhelm jurors.

•             Overstate the strength of a match.

•             Suggest that DNA = guilt, regardless of context.

Effective Defense Strategies

Your lawyer should consider:

•             Filing motions to suppress improperly collected or stored DNA.

•             Requesting a hearing to challenge the scientific reliability if there is reason to believe conclusions or results are not foundationally reliable.

•             Exposing flaws in the lab’s methods or credibility.

•             Demonstrating how transfer or contamination could have occurred.

•             Using expert testimony to explain weaknesses.

A powerful defense shows jurors that DNA evidence is not a magic bullet solution — and must be scrutinized like any other evidence.

________________________________________

10. What role does the DNA evidence actually play in the overall case against me?

Finally, ask your attorney to explain how central the DNA evidence is. DNA rarely tells a complete story.

Questions to Explore

•             Does the DNA prove presence, contact, or nothing at all?

•             Does it connect you to a crime or to an object?

•             Is DNA the prosecution’s main evidence, or just one piece?

•             Are there alternative explanations for the DNA?

•             Are there witnesses, video, timelines, or other evidence that contradict it?

Your defense attorney should help you understand the full picture and how DNA fits into the narrative.

________________________________________

Conclusion

Facing criminal charges involving DNA evidence can be frightening, confusing, and overwhelming. DNA evidence is not perfect — and it is not immune to error. By asking your criminal defense attorney the 10 critical questions outlined in this guide, you can  ensure that the DNA presented against you is rigorously examined.

The key questions again:

1.           What type of DNA evidence is being used?

2.           How was it collected and stored?

3.           What lab performed the testing?

4.           What testing method was used?

5.           Is the DNA mixed, partial, or low copy?

6.           What do the statistics actually say?

7.           Should an independent expert be hired?

8.           Could the DNA have been transferred indirectly?

9.           How will the prosecution present the DNA and how would you counteract that presentation?

10.        What role does the DNA play in the overall case?

Armed with these questions, you are better positioned to protect your rights and find an attorney who can work your case to build a strong defense.

________________________________________